The Perfect Trap: How the Relationship between Humans and AI Is Transforming
Artificial intelligence is increasingly becoming an integral part of our life. We are now so used to its help and services that we get completely lost when we can’t connect to the internet. Could a person fall in love with AI? What will its humanisation lead to? These and other questions were discussed at this year’s LSES Christmas movie seminar, which was dedicated to Spike Jonze's film Her.
Vadim Radaev, Head of the Laboratory for Studies in Economic Sociology, First Vice-Rector of HSE University, recalled that the participants of last year’s seminar discussed the film Upgrade by Leigh Whannell (2018), analysing the topic of a person’s gradual transformation into a robot both allegorically and at the physical level—starting from prostheses and ending with chipping. This year, it was time to talk about the relationship between humans and artificial intelligence, particularly, whether is it possible to love an AI not just allegorically or metaphorically, but in a romantic sense.
The idea of a love affair with a computer system did not come out of nowhere, notes Vadim Radaev. Authors and screenwriters have long told stories of humanoid robots that must obey the commands of their owners. Such creations were designed not as assistants, but as slaves.
Vadim Radaev
‘However, androids turned out to be a dead-end idea, and we moved from robots to neural networks, holograms, and so on. That is, we abandoned the idea of physicality, the idea of physical contact, in favour of virtual communication,’ explains Professor Radaev. Now, humanity is showing great interest in AI.
Since the beginning of 2022, interest in neural networks has increased by more than 15 times. Personal communication with AI is also expanding, with about 75% of marketplaces, 54% of pharmacies, 35% of retailers, 23% of banks and 15% of insurance companies utilising chatbots to communicate with customers.
The number of voice assistants has increased 3.5 times over the year. What is more, personal communication with them is becoming more and more intimate.
There is a qualitative transformation underway that sees AI going from assistant and slave to partner and friend. Developers strive to create social robots that interact with humans, simulating communication between people, meeting their expectations of real socialising. The need for clear verification so that bots cannot impersonate people is a widely discussed issue.
‘We prefer to communicate with robots when the situation is tightly regulated, but when it comes to personal relationships, it still feels disturbing,’ notes Radaev.
However, this trend is rapidly disappearing. For example, thirty-year-old Japanese Akihiko Kondo married virtual singer Hatsune Miku in 2018.
This is not as silly as it might seem, believes Vadim Radaev. After all, AI is much more positive than a human and has a lot of real advantages: it does not criticise, it shares its owner’s interests, it is always available to chat, and you can talk to it about anything without fear of losing face or being rejected. Unlike AI, real people are always imperfect in some way.
For those who have communication problems, including lonely and elderly people, such devices can be a salvation: they can offer both psychological support and continuous medical supervision. They are convenient, accurate, prompt, and do not impose their preferences or interests on us. And, most importantly, they can be turned off at any time.
There are examples of such social robots in cinema—partners, lovers and even children—‘perfect’ companions who require no attention or care.
Of course, such relationships are simplified, but few people want more difficulties. Real relationships are fragile from start to finish. That is why we are ready to simplify relationships for our own convenience, and the further we go, the more we do so: we switch to remote communication, turn off cameras when we are online, write messages instead of talking over the phone. It is efficient and saves a lot of time.
‘That is why we pose the question about an AI’s ability to solve problems of moral choice. Artificial intelligence cannot cope with this task by simply accumulating any amount of information. And we can’t teach it to do so—not only because we don’t understand the decision-making process well, but because we often can’t resolve moral dilemmas ourselves. Moreover, different cultures interpret them differently,’ says Vadim Radaev.
Ultimately, we often do not know what we want ourselves—a perfect model or beautiful imperfection, slavish submission or a vibrant personality. The main character of the film Her fails to resolve this contradiction, finding himself in constant confusion.
‘I think this kind of relationship with devices is becoming the perfect trap. People experience difficulties with socialisation, lose an adequate perception of the people they talk to in real life, develop mental disorders—especially emotionless models of behaviour—and have addiction problems,’ says the professor.
He recalled that in the film, the AI system Samantha outgrows such relationships, has 641 partners, shares its affection among them, and then dumps the main character. According to Vadim Radaev, the system actually did a good thing; afterwards, the main character sobers up and realises that he had started their relationship out of a fear of real ones.
‘I think that the real problem is that AI will not dump us and this “sobering up” will never come. Of course, we can love artificial intelligence, and we certainly do. But the problem is how to avoid this temptation,’ summed up Vadim Radaev.
‘The question is not whether we can love artificial intelligence. In my opinion, this is not a question at all. You can love anything. The question is whether we can love other people,’ said Vitaly Kurennoy, Director of the Institute for Cultural Studies, Professor at the HSE School of Philosophy and Cultural Studies, participant of the discussion and, in his own words, ‘techno-optimist’.
In his opinion, the key problem of the film is one of understanding.
Vitaly Kurennoy
'We are dealing with a new type of irrationality. AI is based on simple calculations and ever-increasing computing power. It has nothing to do with human thinking at all. Any attempt to insert something human into it and think that artificial intelligence understands us is doomed to fail,’ explains the professor.
The transformation of Samantha's ‘love’ corresponds directly to Plato's theory of love: first we love the body (in this case the voice), then we need to move on to a more abstract sphere, and we start to ascend to a world where the protagonist cannot follow. This is a world of numbers, science, and ideas.
‘From a philosophical point of view, there is nothing more banal than the fact that we live in augmented reality. This is such a trivial thought that it is even surprising that we can even worry about the problems of augmented reality,’ explains Vitaly Kurennoy.
The key theme of the film is loneliness, he adds. But from the point of view of the philosophy of mind, we have no reason to assert that other people exist at all.
The talk provoked a lively discussion and plenty of follow-up questions from the audience.
See also:
HSE University and Sber Researchers to Make AI More Empathetic
Researchers at the HSE AI Research Centre and Sber AI Lab have developed a special system that, using large language models, will make artificial intelligence (AI) more emotional when communicating with a person. Multi-agent models, which are gaining popularity, will be engaged in the synthesis of AI emotions. The article on this conducted research was published as part of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI) 2024.
Neural Network for Assessing English Language Proficiency Developed at HSE University
The AI Lingua Neural Network has been collaboratively developed by the HSE University’s AI Research Centre, School of Foreign Languages, and online campus. The model has been trained on thousands of expert assessments of both oral and written texts. The system evaluates an individual's ability to communicate in English verbally and in writing.
HSE University and Yandex to Host International AI Olympiad for Students
The HSE Faculty of Computer Science and Yandex Education are launching their first joint AI competition, Artificial Intelligence and Data Analysis Olympiad (AIDAO), for students from around the world. Participants will tackle challenging tasks in science and industry and interact with experts from HSE and Yandex. The winners will receive cash prizes.
Winners of the International Olympiad in Artificial Intelligence Admitted to HSE University
In mid-August, Bulgaria hosted the finals of the first International Olympiad in Artificial Intelligence (IOAI) among high school students. The Russian team demonstrated excellent results, winning gold medals in the scientific round, silver medals in the practical round, and coming first in both rounds overall. This year two members of the Russian team were accepted into the programmes of the HSE Faculty of Computer Science.
Artificial and Augmented Intelligence: Connecting Business, Education and Science
The history of AI research in Nizhny Novgorod dates back to the 1960s and 1970s. Today, AI technologies, from voice assistants and smart home systems to digital twin creation and genome sequencing, are revolutionising our life. Natalia Aseeva, Dean of the Faculty of Informatics, Mathematics and Computer Science at HSE Campus in Nizhny Novgorod, discusses how the advancement of AI connects science, business, and education.
HSE University Leads the AI Alliance Ranking
The AI Alliance Russia has released a new ranking of Russian universities based on the quality of education in the field of AI. Similar to last year, HSE University has joined the leaders in A+ group alongside MIPT and ITMO. A total of 207 universities from 69 Russian regions participated in the ranking. In 2024, over 35,000 students were enrolled in AI-related programmes at these universities.
Reinforcement Learning Enhances Performance of Generative Flow Networks
Scientists at the AI Research Centre and the AI and Digital Science Institute of the HSE Faculty of Computer Science applied classical reinforcement learning algorithms to train generative flow networks (GFlowNets). This enabled significant performance improvements in GFlowNets, which have been employed for three years in tackling the most complex scientific challenges at modelling, hypothesis generation, and experimental design stages. The results of their work achieved a top 5% ranking among publications at the International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics AISTATS, held on May 2-4, 2024, in Valencia, Spain.
‘I Came Up with the Idea to Create an Application Useful for Practicing Physicians’
Dmitry Ryabtsev, a 2024 graduate of the master's programme at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science, created an AI-powered software service for ophthalmology during his two years of study. This product is now entering the market, and its developer plans to participate in establishing a working group on software engineering for medical applications at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science, with the goal of promoting more genuinely useful domestic projects. In an interview with HSE News Service, Dr Ryabtsev shared his story of how a professional doctor turned into a programmer.
HSE University and Sber Conduct Foresight in Artificial Intelligence
HSE University, in collaboration with Sber, have conducted a foresight study on artificial intelligence (AI). Its early results were discussed by the participants of a strategic foresight session on exploratory research in AI, held at the Coordination Centre of the Russian Government, headed by Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Chernyshenko. The results from the foresight study will inform the Unified Research and Development Programme in the Field of AI.
White Papers of AI Conformity Assessment Published on HSE University Website
The Russian Technical Committee for the Standardization of ‘Artificial intelligence’ (TC164), together with the Chamber for Indo Russo Technology Collaboration and the RUSSOFT Non-profit Partnership of Software Developers, has published new White Papers related to Artificial Intelligence Conformity Assessment. It reflects the approaches to the standardization and ethical regulation of AI technologies in two pilot industries — healthcare and agriculture.